Coronavirus : Positive tests for recovered patients are not reinfections, says WHO
A medical staff member shows a coronavirus nasal swab test sample at a hospital in Liege, Belgium.
GENEVA (AFP) – Coronavirus patients declared recovered who later test positive for the disease are still expelling dead lung cells rather than getting a new infection, the World Health Organisation (WHO) told AFP on Wednesday (May 6).
South Korean health officials reported more than 100 such cases in April, raising concerns that patients who had recovered could become reinfected.
“We are aware that some patients test positive after they clinically recover,” a WHO spokesman told AFP, without making specific reference to the South Korean cases.
“From what we currently know – and this is based on very recent data – it seems they these patients are expelling left over materials from their lungs, as part of the recovery phase.”
People infected with the new coronavirus build up antibodies starting a week or so after infection or the onset of symptoms, research has shown.
But it is still not clear, experts say, whether the body systematically builds up enough immunity to ward off a new attack by the virus or, if it does, how long such immunity lasts.
As for the recovered patients who tested negative and then, weeks later, positive, more research is needed, according to the WHO.
“We need systematic collection of samples from recovered patients to better understand how long they shed live virus,” the spokesman said.
“We also need to understand if this means they can pass the virus to other people – having live virus does not necessarily mean it can be passed to another person.”
In a recent interview with BBC, infectious disease epidemiologist Maria Van Kerhove, part of the WHO’s Health Emergencies Programme, explained the “dead cell” scenario.
“As the lungs heal, there are parts of the lung that are dead cells that are coming up. These are fragments of the lungs that are actually testing positive,” she said.
“It is not infectious virus, it’s not reactivation. It is actually part of the healing process.”
“Does that mean they have immunity? Does that mean they have a strong protection against reinfection? We don’t know the answer to that yet.”
For some viruses, such as the measles, those who contract it are immune for life.
For other coronaviruses such as Sars, immunity lasted from a few months to a couple of years.
The pandemic has now killed more than 257,000 people globally and officially infected nearly 3.7 million, although with only the most serious cases being tested the number is believed to be far higher.
