Payback time for BBC : Delhi HC issues notice to BBC on defamation suit
In the month of January 2023, BBC blatantly aired the two-volume documentary series “India: The Modi Question”. Through the said documentary, BBC claimed that there was rising tensions between India’s Prime Minister Narendra Modi and the country’s Muslim minority; there was an alarming rise of hate crimes and extreme politics in India, particularly targeting the Muslim community.
All the above was based on the Gujarat Riots which had taken place just when Modi had taken over the reigns of the State as the newly elected Chief Minister. The opposition in Gujarat and the ruling Party at Centre had accused Modi of fanning the riots. However subsequently the Courts and the people totally exonerated Modi.
So digging up thisstory after so many years by the BBC itself looked like a sinister plan to destabilise India. After all the Brits love to play their Great Game. However now India can hit back in equal measures. So while the British Govt took no legal action on the BBC in name of “ free speech “, a Gujarat-based non-government organisation (NGO) filed a defamation suit against the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC). Based on the defamation suit the Delhi High Court on Monday issued a notice.
The suit claims that BBC has released a two-episode news documentary titled “India: The Modi Question”. The two episodes are stated to have been published in January 2023.
It is contended that the said documentary/publication contains content which casts a slur on the reputation of the country and also makes false and defamatory imputations and insinuations against the Prime Minister of India, the Indian Judiciary and the Indian criminal justice system.
“It is averred that the aforesaid conduct of the respondents is actionable and has made them liable to damages, as claimed in the suit,” noted the court after going through the suit.
The bench of Justice Sachin Dutta on Monday issued notice to respondent BBC and said, “Issue notice to the respondents through all permissible modes, returnable on 25.09.2023”
Senior Advocate Harish Salve appeared for the plaintiff organisation and submitted that the documentary has defamed India and the judiciary also.
Recently Delhi’s Rohini court had also issued summons to the BBC, the Wikimedia Foundation and Internet Archive on a plea seeking a direction restraining the defendants from publishing the BBC documentary based on PM Modi.
The petitioner Binay Kumar Singh has petitioned the Rohini district court to pass an order restraining the Defendants restraining them including their agents, etc. to cease the publishing of the two-volume documentary series “India: The Modi Question” or any other defamatory material pertaining to the Plaintiff, Rashtriya Swayamsewak Sangh (RSS) and Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) on the platforms of Wikimedia and Internet Archive or any other online or offline platforms.
He has also sought to pass a direction to the defendants ordering them to tender an unconditional apology to the Plaintiff as well as to RSS and VHP for the libellous and defamatory content published in the two-volume documentary series.
